Another line of testing done to support
the biological perspective are neuroendocrine studies. The neuroendocrine viewpoint's basic
hypothesis is that sexual orientation is determined by the early levels
(probably prenatal) of androgen on relevant neural structures [7]. If highly exposed to these androgens, the fetus
will become masculinized, or attracted to females. This research was conducted on rats at
Stanford. The adult female rats that
received male-typical levels of androgens sufficiently early in development
exhibited male symptoms of attraction.
The same was true in the reverse when applied to the male subjects. The female exposed to high levels of the
hormone exhibited high levels of aggression and sexual drive toward other
females, eventually trying to mount the other females in an act of reproduction. In the males, the subject who received
deficient levels of androgen became submissive in matters of sexual drive and
reproduction and were willing to receive the sexual act of the other male rat
[7].
A popular route of experimentation in
general psychology also did not elude the biological argument. Twin studies have become a highly debated
area of experimentation. Ernest Kallman
conducted the earliest twin study. He
found a 100% concordance between monozygotic (or identical) twins (MZ), and
only a 12% concordance for dizygotic (or fraternal) twins (DZ). Although discredited with methodological
problems, the early experiment paved the way for a much-publicized team to
conduct their twin studies.
J. Michael Bailey and Richard Pillard also
studied the gayness between MZ twins, DZ twins, and non-related adopted
brothers. They examined how many of the
sample population examined were gay and how many were straight. They found that 52% of MZ twins were both
self-identified homosexuals, 22% of DZ twins were so, and only 5% of
non-related adopted brothers were so.
This evidence, repeated and found to be true a second time, showed to
the biological camp that the more closely genetically linked a pair is, the
more likely they both are to exhibit gay or straight tendencies. Later experimenters found similar evidence in
females. One such scientist is Dean
Hamer. Hamer examined the possibility of homosexuality being an X-linked
trait. He examined the family trees of
openly gay men, and thought he saw a maternal link, leading him to investigate
his theory of X-linkage. He took 40 DNA
samples from homosexual men, and genetically examined them. He found that there was a 'remarkable
concordance' for 5 genetic markers on section of the X-Chromosome called Xq28
[2].
Hamer hypothesized
upon examining the family trees of the same men that on each subject's mother's
side, there were markedly larger numbers of homosexual men, all stemming
through the maternal lineages. This
observation, along with his startling discovery on Xq28, led his findings to be
dubbed the "gay gene study".
The statistical probability of the 5 genetic markers on Xq28 to have
matched randomly was calculated to be 1/100,000 [2], lending even more support
to his findings.
This finding of a
possible 'gay gene' prompts a look into two evolutionary concepts, and how they
are affected. The Superior Heterozygote
Theory states the phenotypic (actual) expression of homosexuality is the result
of homozygosity for recessive (non-expressed but present) genes [11]. In simplification, if the person's genetic
code is heterozygotic (one homosexual gene and one heterosexual gene), if the
homosexual allele (half of the genetic code) is the allele passed on to the
next generation, it will become the phenotype.
Heterozygotes are only capable of being passed through to the next
generation by mothers (as the Y-chromosome is incapable of heterozygosity),
this again links homosexuality to X-linkage.
No comments:
Post a Comment